| HOME | ARCHIVE | SEARCH | TABLE OF CONTENTS |
|---|
| ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
a OPTIMA, Radcliffe Infirmary, Oxford, United Kingdom
b Research Laboratory for Archaeology, University of Oxford, United Kingdom
Jonathan H. Williams, OPTIMA, Radcliffe Infirmary, Woodstock Road, Oxford OX2 6HE, United Kingdom E-mail: jonathan.williams{at}pharmacology.ox.ac.uk.
| Abstract |
|---|
|
|
|---|
15N) of body proteins can estimate long-term dietary habits in a way that does not depend on memory.
15N is high in people who eat a lot of fish and low in vegetarians.
Methods. To choose between the vegetarian and fish hypotheses of AD, we compared dietary questionnaire reports and
15N of hair samples from AD patients and controls.
Results. Patients' cognitive scores related directly to reported frequency of eating fish and to hair
15NAIR, but inversely to reported frequency of eating beans. Homocysteine levels related inversely to hair
15NAIR in controls, but not in patients. Dietary questionnaire reports accounted for slightly more variance in
15NAIR in patients than controls. Therefore, our questionnaire assessed dietary habits as reliably for individuals with AD as for cognitively unimpaired controls.
Conclusions. A diet rich in fish may ameliorate AD, possibly by lowering homocysteine, but more vegetarian diets do not. In fact, eating beans correlated with worse cognition in AD patients. Further studies should test if restricting the intake of beans slows the progression of AD.
MANY researchers have proposed that dietary factors contribute to Alzheimer's disease (AD). On this view, diet and/or the absorption of nutrients should differ between patients with AD and controls. Most studies have assessed diet in AD by questionnaires (1)(2). However, memory problems may limit such assessments. Our first goal was to assess the accuracy of dietary questionnaire reports in AD. To do this, we supplemented a dietary questionnaire with analyses of 15N:14N isotopic ratios (
15N) in protein from elderly patients with AD and healthy controls.
15N provides a broad indication of dietary protein sources in a way that does not depend on memory. The technique is a common method of dietary assessment in ecology and archeology (3)(4)(5)(6)(7)(8).
15N reflects the position of a dietary protein source in the food chain and can also distinguish between marine and terrestrial protein sources. It is low in vegetable and plant proteins, intermediate in common terrestrial animal proteins (milk, meat from ungulates), and higher in seafoods (fish, shellfish), because marine food chains are generally longer (9). Humans derive all their nitrogen from their diet, so a person's
15N integrates the
15N in their dietary sources (10) over long periods (11). Consequently, people who habitually eat more fish have higher
15N, and vegans have lower
15N than those whose dietary protein is derived mainly from terrestrial animal (meat, dairy) foods (11)(12)(13)(14).
15N is a nonspecific measure: quite different categories of foods may have similar
15N, and people who eat a balanced range of vegetable, dairy, and fish proteins should have the same
15N as those who eat only terrestrial meats. Nevertheless,
15N measures can help to assess if dietary questionnaire reports are as accurate for AD patients as for healthy aged controls.
Dietary theories of AD include proposals that AD patients are deficient in omega-3 fatty acids (15) or that a vegetarian diet protects against AD (16).
15N indexes an individual's position on the food chain (see above). So, the hypothesis that a vegetarian diet protects against AD (16) predicts that patients with AD should have higher
15N. Conversely, the hypothesis (15) that fish oils protect against AD predicts that AD patients would have lower
15N. Our second goal was to measure
15N to choose between these competing hypotheses.
High homocysteine is a risk factor for AD (17)(18). Homocysteine levels depend partly on diet. Foods containing methionine increase homocysteine (19)(20)(21)(22), but those containing folate (e.g., fresh fruit) (23)(24) or vitamin B12 (e.g., meat) (19) lower it. This raises the question whether high homocysteine levels in patients with AD reflect differences in their diet or in their metabolism of folate and methionine. Our third goal was to choose between these alternatives, by testing whether homocysteine showed similar relations to
15N in AD patients and controls.
Our final goal was to test if dietary factors relate to the severity of AD. If dietary factors modulate the progression of AD, then establishing such relations would be an important step toward interventional studies of dietary constituents in AD.
| Methods |
|---|
|
|
|---|
15N (see below). Participants (or carers) also completed a semiquantitative dietary questionnaire (see Appendix) to assess their average frequency of eating meat, fish, dairy products, maize, staples (bread, pasta, or rice), and fresh fruit and vegetables. Our questionnaire asked for the frequency of eating different foods in a manner similar to that validated by a large trial (28)(29).
Nitrogen isotopic analysis of hair samples was as detailed in O'Connell and Hedges (11). Samples were cleaned using organic solvents and water to remove dirt, lipid, or shampoo residues, then wrapped lengthways in aluminum foil, cut into 1.5-cm sections, dried under vacuum, and rolled into balls. Isotopic analyses were performed using an automated elemental analyzer (Carlo Erba, Milan, Italy) coupled to a Geo 20/20 isotope ratio mass spectrometer (PDZ Europa, Crewe, United Kingdom). We corrected results for mass dependence by comparison with laboratory standards run in conjunction with the samples. All results in this article are reported using the
notation in units of permil (
) relative to the international standard AIR (30):
15NAIR = [(15/14Nsample /15/14NAIR) - 1] x 1000. We analyzed each sample in duplicate: replicate measurement errors on standards were less than ±0.2%. Variations in hair pigmentation and treatment processes do not affect isotopic analyses (11)(14).
We analyzed differences in single variables between patient and control groups using nonparametric statistics:
2, Wilcoxon-Mann-Whitney z (WMW z). The dietary questionnaire reports were only semiquantitative, so we analyzed their relations to other variables using polychoric correlations (which give unbiased estimates of relationship for variables of this kind) (31).
Homocysteine levels depend on age, gender, and levels of folate and vitamin B12 (32). The mean red cell volume (MCV) provides a biological marker of vitamin B12 and homocysteine levels (33). We tested the dependence of homocysteine upon
15NAIR and the other variables using multiple linear regression. The regression first fitted the main effect of each independent variable. It then fitted the interactions of these variables with patient status. Finally, it dropped any nonsignificant interactions or main effects. We analyzed the dependence of cognitive performance (CAMCOG scores) upon the same variables using a similar multiple regression that included homocysteine as an independent variable.
| Results |
|---|
|
|
|---|
2 = 1.8, 1 df, p > .1; age: WMW z = 1.35, p = .18). Overall, the mean
15NAIR was 9.02% ± 0.40 (SD), and the mean homocysteine level was 12.84 ± 4.87 (SD) µmol/l.
Relations Between
15NAIR and Dietary Questionnaire Reports in Patients and Controls
Overall,
15NAIR correlated positively with reported frequency of eating fish (polychoric correlation = 0.39, n = 107, p = .001) (Fig. 1), but negatively with that of eating beans (polychoric correlation = -0.29, n = 107, p = .02) (Fig. 2). Analysis of variance with polynomial trends showed that
15NAIR fell with more frequent reported bean consumption in controls (F = 7.80; 1/101 df; p = .006), but fell even more sharply in patients (Patient x Beans interaction: F = 4.13; 1/101 df; p = .044) (see Fig. 2).
|
|
15NAIR
.2). We analyzed this further by computing the arithmetic difference between the questionnaire scores for fish and meat intake. Analysis of this difference score indicated that patients take more of their nondairy animal protein as meat and less as fish, compared to controls (WMW z = 2.16, p < .031). Overall
15NAIR levels were similar for patients and controls (WMW z = 1.33; p = .2), but the severity of patients' AD related to their
15NAIR (see below).
Relation of Homocysteine to
15NAIR
Patients' homocysteine levels were higher than controls' (WMW z = 2.60, p = .009) (as reported previously in the OPTIMA cohort [17]). This remained significant (t = 1.97, p = .05) in the multiple regression that covaried serum folate (t = 5.75, p < .001), age (t = 2.93, p = .004), and mean cell volume (t = 2.64, p = .01). In this final multiple regression model, two interactions were significant. First, homocysteine levels related inversely to
15NAIR (t = -2.39, p = .019) in controls, but not in the patients (
15NAIR x Patient interaction: t = 2.02, p = .046) (Fig. 3). Second, homocysteine related directly to MCV in the controls (t = 3.54, p = .001), but not in the patients (MCV x Patient interaction: t = 2.30; p = .024) (not shown).
|
15NAIR and Dietary Questionnaire Reports
15NAIR levels related directly to CAMCOG scores in the patients but not in the controls (Patient x
15NAIR interaction: t = 4.34, p < .001) (Fig. 4).
15NAIR accounted for 27.0% of the variance in patients' CAMCOG scores (t = 3.22, p = .003), even after covarying homocysteine (Patient x
15NAIR: t = 4.37, p < .001).
|
|
| Discussion |
|---|
|
|
|---|
15NAIR was higher in people who reported eating fish more frequently (see Fig. 1), exactly in line with observations from previous studies (12)(13)(14).
15NAIR was also lower in those who reported eating beans more frequently (Fig. 2). Beans and legumes derive from nitrogen-fixing plants, which have lower
15NAIR than other plants (34)(35), so eating more beans should lower
15NAIR, as we found. These results, therefore, indicate that our food frequency questionnaire tapped meaningful differences in individuals' dietary preferences. In fact, the dietary questionnaire responses accounted for 1520% of the variance in
15NAIR. At first, this may suggest that the dietary questionnaire reports were inaccurate. However, several factors could dilute the correlation between
15NAIR and the questionnaire responses. First, our questionnaire asked about the frequency of eating different types of foods, which relates imperfectly to the quantities eaten (29). Second, most preprocessed foods (e.g., biscuits) contain many ingredients, which participants probably did not take into account in their questionnaire responses. Third,
15N is not very food-specific (see introduction), and individual variations in
15N can only reflect relatively extreme dietary propensities. This limitation dilutes the relationship between the dietary reports and
15N and makes
15N unsuitable for testing if eating proteins from terrestrial animals relates to AD. Fourth, hair grows at about 1 cm per month (36), but its
15N is an integrated average of the isotopic composition of an individual's diet over the majority of the year prior to its growth (11)(37). This is an advantage of our isotopic analyses over the dietary questionnaire responses: the latter are more likely to reflect participants' dietary intake over only the previous few days or weeks. In light of these limitations, the fact that the dietary questionnaire responses accounted for 1520% of the variance in
15NAIR is more impressive. We conclude that, overall,
15NAIR and our questionnaire both reliably tap individuals' enduring dietary preferences. The two methods are complementarythe questionnaire emphasizes the frequency of eating different foods, but
15N probably relates more strongly to the quantities eaten.
Reliability of Dietary Questionnaires in AD
Our findings indicate that questionnaire reports of dietary habits from patients with AD are just as good as, or even better than, controls. Dietary questionnaire reports accounted for slightly more variance in
15NAIR in patients (R2 = .19) than controls (R2 = .15). Probably, patients could not recall their diet, and their carers supplied much of this information. Such second-hand information should be less reliable than the first-hand information from controls. However, it is hard to see how such information dilution could explain how
15NAIR related (inversely) to the frequency of eating beans more strongly in patients than controls (Fig. 2). Patients with AD may prefer more sweet foods (38), but this cannot readily account for their stronger relation between
15NAIR and their reported consumption of beans, nor could institutionalization, because all patients were community-dwelling. Therefore, we conclude that our questionnaire assessed dietary habits as reliably for individuals with AD as for cognitively unimpaired controls.
Implications of Our Results for Vegetarian and Dietary Fish Hypotheses of AD
Our second goal was to choose between the competing hypotheses that either a vegetarian diet (16) or a diet rich in fish (15) may protect against AD. Although correlational, our findings militate against the vegetarian hypothesis. Instead, they offered slight support to the fish hypothesis (15), because the AD patients took a slightly lower proportion of their animal protein as fish, compared to controls. The fact that the overall
15N distributions were similar for patients and controls is not consistent with either of the hypotheses that fish or vegetarian diets are protective against AD. However, after accounting for bean consumption, patients who reported eating less fish had lower CAMCOG scores. This was not merely due to better recall of eating fish in patients with lesser cognitive impairments, because patients' CAMCOG scores also related directly to their
15N (providing independent evidence that they ate more fish protein). Hence, possibly, a diet rich in fish may slow the progression of AD. However, our observational study cannot distinguish if reduced frequency of eating fish by more impaired patients is a cause or effect of their memory problems. Further experimental studies should test this.
Implications of Our Results for the Homocysteine Hypothesis of AD
Our findings suggest that high homocysteine levels in AD patients (17)(18) relate to changes in metabolism, rather than differences in diet. Homocysteine levels related to
15NAIR only in controls (Fig. 3). This indicates that controls who ate more animal protein, especially fish, had lower homocysteine. This is consistent with previous observational studies (19) and with evidence that dietary supplements of fish oils can lower homocysteine (39). In contrast to controls, homocysteine did not relate to
15NAIR in patients. This suggests that patients' higher homocysteine resulted from changes in their absorption or metabolism of methionine, folate, or B12, rather than their diet. Further studies should confirm our findings and test if dietary modifications or supplements can lower homocysteine levels in AD.
Relationship of Dietary Reports to Severity of AD
Our correlational results indicated that dietary factors relate to the severity of AD, but they cannot illuminate the mechanism of this relationship. AD is chronic, so that although
15NAIR integrates information about dietary habits over the preceding year, the disease started before that time. We are thus unable to know if the dietary changes that we found are causes, effects, or correlates of the severity of AD. (For example, the main maize-based food that people eat in this country is breakfast cereal, which may be their main source of folate (40). So, the correlation of eating maize-based foods with CAMCOG may reflect effects of folate on CAMCOG [17], rather than any quality intrinsic to maize.) However, our results suggest a need for interventional studies to test the possibility that dietary factors may modulate the severity of AD. In particular, patients who reported eating more beans had lower CAMCOG scores (Fig. 5). The fact that the controls showed a similar, though not quite significant, trend reinforces this unexpected result and tends to exclude the possibility that participants ate more beans due to impaired cognition. The finding that CAMCOG correlates with reported consumption of beans, but not other plant foods, is not easy to explain. One possibility is that beans contain a higher level of antinutrients, such as phytates, that could impair the absorption or metabolism of other micronutrients. Further studies should confirm our findings in population-derived samples and test if restricting the frequency of eating beans prevents cognitive deterioration in patients with AD.
| Acknowledgments |
|---|
We thank the participants in OPTIMA who completed the dietary questionnaire and provided the hair samples. We also thank the OPTIMA nurses for obtaining the hair samples. We thank the editor and an anonymous reviewer for constructive criticism of the manuscript.
Received February 21, 2002
Accepted June 6, 2002
| Appendix |
|---|
|
|
|---|
|
| References |
|---|
|
|
|---|
13C and
15N in contemporary Japanese hair: a stochastic method for estimating multi-source contribution by double isotopic tracers. Appl Geochem 7:145-158.
This article has been cited by other articles:
![]() |
E. Nurk, C. A Drevon, H. Refsum, K. Solvoll, S. E Vollset, O. Nygard, H. A Nygaard, K. Engedal, G. S Tell, and A D. Smith Cognitive performance among the elderly and dietary fish intake: the Hordaland Health Study Am. J. Clinical Nutrition, November 1, 2007; 86(5): 1470 - 1478. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
| ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| HOME | ARCHIVE | SEARCH | TABLE OF CONTENTS |
|---|