| HOME | ARCHIVE | SEARCH | TABLE OF CONTENTS |
|---|
| ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
a Department of Medicine and Center on Aging, The University of Texas Medical Branch, Galveston.
Shiva Satish, Center on Aging, UTMB, 301 University Blvd., Galveston, TX 77555-0460 E-mail: ssatish{at}utmb.edu.
Decision Editor: John E. Morley, MB, BCh
| Abstract |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Methods. This is a cross-sectional study of 507 noninstitutionalized tri-ethnic men and women aged 75 and older living in Galveston County, Texas. A home interview collected data on demographics, chronic medical conditions, cognition, depression, and functional status. Site, severity, and duration of rheumatologic symptoms such as morning stiffness, body tenderness, and body aching in the past month were also collected.
Results. There was a high prevalence of nonspecific rheumatologic symptoms such as morning stiffness (32% in the shoulder girdle, 31% in the hip girdle), tenderness to touch (9%), and generalized body aching (11%) in the study population. Twenty-one percent of the subjects reported either bilateral shoulder or hip girdle stiffness or tenderness lasting more than 30 minutes almost every day or every day or generalized body aching most of the time during the past month. Age-, gender-, and ethnicity-adjusted multivariate analyses showed that more than three self-reported chronic medical conditions, poor or fair self-reported health, impairment in instrumental activities of daily living (IADL), and the presence of depressive or anxiety symptoms were associated with the presence of these chronic rheumatologic symptoms.
Conclusion. Chronic rheumatologic symptoms are common in people aged 75 and older. Such symptoms are markers for underlying poor health and for anxiety and depression among older subjects.
MUSCULOSKELETAL disorders are the leading cause of pain and disability among people aged 65 years and older (1)(2)(3). Nearly two-thirds of the women and more than half of the men in this population present to their physicians with pain or limitations of function related to a musculoskeletal disorder (2).
Diagnosing specific musculoskeletal disorders in older adults presents a unique challenge. Radiologic findings of osteoarthritis are highly prevalent but correlate poorly with symptoms and physical findings (4). Commonly used serologic tests, such as rheumatoid factor and antinuclear antibodies, have very poor positive predictive value in elderly persons (5). In addition, nonspecific rheumatologic symptoms such as morning stiffness, muscle tenderness, or total body aching overlap with a broad range of disorders including rheumatoid arthritis, polymyalgia rheumatica (PMR), and fibromyalgia.
Somatic complaints in the elderly population are very common (1)(2)(6). Elderly patients have multiple chronic medical conditions that may contribute to the overall somatic complaints, which masks the specificity of musculoskeletal disorders. Whereas the prevalence of joint pain and physician-diagnosed arthritis has been relatively well studied, there is very little information on the prevalence of the nonspecific rheumatologic symptoms such as stiffness, tenderness, and fatigue, particularly among older populations. Because there are often no gold standards in diagnosing musculoskeletal disorders in elderly persons, the high prevalence of musculoskeletal complaints tends to obscure the recognition of these specific diseases.
The purpose of this population-based study of men and women aged 75 and over is to describe the prevalence of nonspecific rheumatologic symptoms such as morning stiffness, muscle tenderness, and generalized body aching among three ethnic groups. We also examine the relationship between these symptoms and chronic medical conditions, functional status, and other measures of health status.
| Methods |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Trained bilingual interviewers conducted in-home interviews. Interviews were conducted in either Spanish or English, depending on subject preference. Fifteen percent
of the interviews were conducted with a knowledgeable proxy respondent because those subjects were too ill or were believed by family members to be cognitively impaired. As compared with respondents included in this study sample, proxy subjects were more likely to be older than 80 years of age (65% vs 55%), were more likely to be Hispanic Americans (50% vs 30%), and were more likely to have had fewer than 8 years of education (100% vs 51%). Proxy data were excluded from the current analyses due to a lack of information pertaining to the objectives studied. As a result, our study sample consisted of 507 individuals including 177 African Americans, 153 Hispanic Americans, and 177 non-Hispanic white Americans.
Data collected included age, marital status, annual income, level of education, living arrangements, chronic medical conditions, self-reported health status, and functional status. Chronic medical conditions were assessed by asking subjects if they have been told by a physician that they had any of the following diseases: stroke, cancer, diabetes, hypertension, osteoporosis, kidney disease, prostate problems, respiratory problems, hip fracture, heart disease, and arthritis. These questions were similar to questions used in the Established Populations for Epidemiologic Studies of the Elderly to assess health conditions (8). Depressive symptoms were measured with the Center for Epidemiologic StudiesDepression Scale (CES-D) (9)(10). The CES-D contains 20 items, each corresponding to a specific symptom of depression. The frequency with which each symptom had been experienced in the preceding week was assessed on 4-point scale. Anxiety symptoms were measured with the Zung Self Rating Anxiety Scale (Zung SAS) (11). This scale is based on the presence of 20 specific anxiety symptoms during the past week. Cognitive impairment was assessed using the Pfeiffer Mini Mental Exam (12). Subjects' self-care abilities were measured using the Katz Activities of Daily Living scale (ADL) (13) and the instrumental activities of daily living (IADL) (14).
Subjects were also asked a series of questions to assess their nonspecific rheumatological symptoms in the past month. Arthritis symptom questions used in The National Health and Nutrition Examination Survey were modified in this study to assess more nonspecific rheumatological symptoms (15). Similar questions have also been used in Hispanic Established Populations for Epidemiologic Study of the Elderly (16). Self-reports of musculoskeletal symptoms in elderly subjects have been shown to be valid in comparison to a standardized physician examination (17). Subjects were asked whether they had experienced any specific rheumatologic symptoms such as morning stiffness, muscle tenderness, or generalized body aching in the past month. For those who responded yes to the above question, the duration and distribution of these symptoms were also determined. For example, "In the past month how often did you wake up with stiffness in your upper arms or shoulders? Is it a few times, about half of the time, almost every day, every day?" For those who responded yes to any of the above options were asked, "Was this stiffness on one side only or both sides?", "How long did this stiffness usually last? Is it less than 30 minutes, 3059 minutes, 1 hour or more, most of the day or all day?" Similar questions were asked regarding stiffness in the hips and thighs. Information on muscle tenderness was obtained by asking, "In the past month were the muscles of your shoulders or arms tender to the touch most of the time? Was this on one side or both sides?" Similar questions were asked regarding tenderness in the hips and thighs. Generalized body aching was assessed by asking whether the statement "I ached all over my body most of the time in the past month" was true, partly true, or not true at all. Subjects who responded "true" were considered to have generalized body aching most of the time in the past month. Subjects who reported the presence of (i) bilateral morning stiffness either in the shoulders or the hips, lasting more than 30 minutes, every day or almost every day during the past month; (ii) bilateral muscle tenderness either in shoulders or hips, most of the time during the past month; or (iii) generalized body aching most of the time during the past month were defined as a subgroup with chronic rheumatologic symptoms.
Data Analysis
All analyses in this study were conducted with weighted data to reflect the overall population of adults aged 75 and older in Galveston County, Texas, using SUDAAN version 7.5 (Research Triangle Institute, Research Triangle Park, NC) (18). Data were dichotomized on the basis of demographic, medical, and functional characteristics as follows: age <80 versus
80 years, education
8 versus >8 years, and annual income <$15,000 versus
$15,000/year. Subjects were also dichotomized on the basis of the number of chronic medical conditions (
3 or >3) and of their self-reported health status as excellent/good versus fair/poor. Subjects scoring 16 or more points in the CES-D scale were considered to have high depressive symptoms, those scoring
12 were considered to have high anxiety symptoms, and those subjects scoring
6 in the Pfeiffer Mini Mental Exam were considered cognitively impaired. Subjects were considered to have depressive or anxiety symptoms if they scored either 16 or more points in the CES-D scale or 12 or more points in the Zung SAS. Subjects were classified as functionally impaired in ADL or IADL if they needed help with one or more activities. The prevalence of chronic nonspecific rheumatologic symptoms was described using simple cross-tabulations. Cross-tabulations with chi square analyses were done to describe the demographic and medical characteristics associated with chronic rheumatologic symptoms.
The purpose of our analyses was to identify the clinically accessible factors associated with chronic rheumatologic symptoms. Because we did not collect all the potential independent factors associated with chronic rheumatologic symptoms, we ran a series of logistic regression models adjusting only for age, gender, and race to assess the magnitude of association between clinically relevant individual characteristics with chronic rheumatologic symptoms. The analyses were considered significant if the p value was
.05.
| Results |
|---|
|
|
|---|
|
|
|
|
| Discussion |
|---|
|
|
|---|
The association between anxiety and depression on the one hand and nonspecific rheumatologic symptoms on the other may be causal, but it is unclear in what direction the causality flows. The increased prevalence of depressive and anxiety symptoms could be explained as depression and anxiety presenting with somatic symptoms or, alternatively, the presence of chronic rheumatologic symptoms could contribute to depression and anxiety (19).
Depression and anxiety have been reported to be highly prevalent but are underdiagnosed in the older population (20)(21)(22)(23). Depressive symptoms are particularly common in persons older than 75 years. Even minor and subsyndromal depressive and anxiety symptoms are associated with excess morbidity, increased functional impairment, and health service use (24)(25). For the clinician, the presence of chronic rheumatologic symptoms in an older patient might serve as a prompt to screen for depression or anxiety.
In bivariate analyses, African Americans had the highest prevalence of chronic rheumatologic symptoms, whereas Hispanic Americans had the lowest prevalence compared with non-Hispanic whites. These differences probably reflect differences in the underlying prevalence of comorbidity, and anxiety, and depression in these three ethnic groups (Table 1 ), because there were no differences in rheumatologic symptoms by ethnicity in multivariate analyses that included comorbidity, anxiety, and depression.
The constellation of prolonged shoulder and hip girdle stiffness or tenderness, or aching all over, is similar to the presentation of PMR (26). PMR is a disease that inflicts elderly persons and is typified by proximal muscle aching or stiffness or tenderness, an elevated erythrocyte sedimentation rate, and a prompt and dramatic response to a therapeutic trial of low-dose corticosteroids. PMR is often unrecognized in the community (26)(27)(28). This would appear to be true particularly among ethnic groups with poor access to medical care (27). The findings of the current study suggest that one contributing factor to the under-recognition of PMR is the high background of rheumatic symptoms in the general population of older patients. With 20% of the elderly population experiencing symptoms reminiscent of PMR, it may be difficult for primary care physicians to recognize the 1% who actually have PMR. Subjects with late complications of medical conditions such as stroke, diabetes, or chronic renal failure can present with similar nonspecific rheumatological symptoms. In our study, subjects with a history of arthritis (OR 5.1, 95% CI 2.5, 10.5) or diabetes (OR 2.4, 95% CI 1.1, 5.4) were more likely to experience these chronic rheumatological symptoms.
The presence of musculoskeletal pain has been shown to be associated with physical disability in community-dwelling elderly persons (29)(30). We found an association between the presence of chronic nonspecific rheumatologic symptoms and the impairment in the performance of the IADL but not of the ADL.
This investigation should be interpreted with recognition of the limitations in its methodology. The degree in which these findings in Galveston County, Texas can be extrapolated to other geographic areas is unclear. The majority of the non-Hispanic whites and African Americans in our study were born in the Galveston area, whereas half of the older Hispanics were born in Mexico. In addition, although this was a population-based sample, it excluded certain frail older subjects such as those institutionalized and those for whom a proxy interview was obtained. A small proportion of elderly persons who were not on the HCFA rolls (i.e., those without Medicare coverage) were also excluded. Finally, in this cross sectional study, we cannot infer any causal relationships between chronic rheumatologic symptoms and the presence of anxiety or depression symptoms.
In conclusion, nonspecific rheumatologic symptoms are common in the population aged 75 and older. It would appear that such symptoms are particularly frequent among older patients with symptoms of anxiety or depression. Such symptoms should prompt the physician to screen for those conditions.
| Acknowledgments |
|---|
| Footnotes |
|---|
This manuscript was presented as a poster at the 52nd Annual Scientific Meeting of Gerontological Society of America at San Francisco, California, November 1999.
Received November 11, 1999
Accepted April 28, 2000
| References |
|---|
|
|
|---|
This article has been cited by other articles:
![]() |
W. van Lankveld, M. Franssen, and A. Stenger Gerontorheumatology: the challenge to meet health-care demands for the elderly with musculoskeletal conditions Rheumatology, April 1, 2005; 44(4): 419 - 422. [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
J. E. Morley, H. M. Perry III, and D. K. Miller Editorial: Something About Frailty J. Gerontol. A Biol. Sci. Med. Sci., November 1, 2002; 57(11): M698 - 704. [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
| ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| HOME | ARCHIVE | SEARCH | TABLE OF CONTENTS |
|---|