| HOME | ARCHIVE | SEARCH | TABLE OF CONTENTS |
|---|
| ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
a Istituto di Medicina Interna e Geriatria, CE.M.I., Università Cattolica del Sacro Cuore, Rome, Italy
b Center for Gerontology and Health Care Research, Brown University, Providence, Rhode Island
c Sticht Center on Aging, Wake Forest University, Winston-Salem, North Carolina
Claudio Pedone, Center for Gerontology and Health Care Research, Brown University, 171 Meeting Street, Providence, RI 02912 E-mail: Claudio_Pedone{at}Brown.edu.
Decision Editor: John E. Morley, MB, BCh
| Abstract |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Methods. A total of 1239 patients (mean age 77.8 ± 7.1 years, range 65100 years, males 49.8%) consecutively admitted to 69 General Medicine and Geriatrics wards over a 4-month period were grouped by combining two dichotomous factors (Carlson's score >4: definite or possible diagnosis of CHF; Carlson's score <5: unlikely diagnosis of CHF; in-hospital adoption of digitalis therapy: yes or no) as follows: Group A: Carlson's score >4, digitalis (n = 413); Group B: Carlson's score >4, no digitalis (n = 260); Group C: Carlson's score <5, digitalis (n = 104); Group D: Carlson's score <5, no digitalis (n = 462). Variables significantly distinguishing groups were entered into a discriminant analysis aimed at assessing the group specificity of individual clinical profiles.
Results. Use of digoxin at home, atrial fibrillation, older age, and comorbidity (mainly COPD and chronic renal failure) characterized most of the patients given digoxin with or without a definite diagnosis of CHF. Clinical profiles of groups A, B, and C largely overlapped.
Conclusion. Age, historical use of digitalis, and comorbidity might lead to seemingly incongruous digitalis prescription. The choice of adopting digitalis therapy cannot be reliably predicted on the basis of clinical variables only. Presently unexplored physician-related factors, such as cultural background, likely outweigh clinical variables in prompting digitalis prescription.
THE rapidly expanding spectrum of therapeutic options for the treatment of congestive heart failure (CHF) has led to a reduction in the use of digitalis. The effectiveness of this drug in reducing mortality is not proven, although a reduction in hospitalizations has been shown (1). Thus, digitalis is no longer considered the mainstay of CHF therapy (2)(3) but can be used to improve symptoms of mild to moderate CHF (4).
Age-related increases in the prevalence of risk factors for digitalis toxicity (e.g., polypharmacy, electrolyte imbalance, and renal failure) (5)(6) make the decision to use digitalis in elderly CHF patients difficult.
The aim of this study is to verify whether the clinical profile on admission can be used to recognize the reason for the use of digitalis.
| Methods |
|---|
|
|
|---|
On the day of admission, each patient underwent a multidimensional assessment exploring sociodemographic status and health-related behaviors, functional capabilities as measured by the activities of daily living (ADLs) (8), and mental function as measured by the Abbreviated Mental Test (AMT) (9). Active diagnoses were coded using the International Classification of Disease, 9th revision, Clinical Modification (10). Pharmacological therapy was assessed by requesting the patient and, if necessary, their relatives or caregivers to display drug containers used in the 2 weeks prior to admission or to recall the names of the drugs if containers were not available. Drugs prescribed during the stay were recorded daily and were classified into therapeutic categories according to Anatomical, Therapeutical, and Chemical codes (11).
On the day of admission, the study physician completed a form recording symptoms and signs of CHF according to Carlson (12). This form includes three categories of symptoms and signs in patient history, physical examination, and chest radiography. Each symptom or sign has a score that is directly proportional to its diagnostic importance (i.e., to the contribution that an individual criterion provides to the correlation between the final score and the pulmonary wedge pressure). Items explored and their respective point values are reported in A. The cumulative CHF score of the individual patient can range from 0 to 12. The diagnosis of CHF is considered to be definite if the score is greater than 7, possible for a score of 5 to 7, and unlikely for a score less than 5 (12).
Patients with a possible or definite diagnosis of CHF with or without atrial fibrillation (score >4) were allocated to Group A if they had a digitalis prescription or Group B otherwise. Patients with a score <5, with or without atrial fibrillation, and taking digitalis were allocated to Group C. The remaining patients were allocated to Group D.
Statistical Analysis
The distribution of sociodemographic, medical, functional, and pharmacological data were compared across groups using chi square tests and an ANOVA test corrected for multiple comparisons as appropriate. Variables collected on admission that significantly distinguished groups in univariate analysis were entered into a discriminant analysis to compare clinical profiles of groups and to identify variables with the highest discriminant power. The Wilks' lambda value was computed to assess the significance of the discriminant function. The Box's M test was computed to estimate the risk of misclassification of individual clinical profiles (13).
Discriminant analysis allows the characterization of the clinical profiles of individual patients and comparison with the group-specific clinical profile. The final objective of the analysis was to verify whether a well-defined clinical profile characterized patients receiving digitalis (i.e., to recognize the rationale for prescribing digitalis).
Statistical analysis was performed using SPSS Version 9 (SPSS Inc., Chicago, IL) (14).
| Results |
|---|
|
|
|---|
|
The prevalence of atrial fibrillation was about 30% in patients receiving digitalis regardless of CHF diagnosis and was 2.7% in CHF patients not receiving digitalis. Use of digitalis at home was strongly correlated with subsequent in-hospital use of this drug.
Table 2 compares the use of selected drugs in the four groups of patients. Diuretics, ACE-inhibitors, and other vasodilators were prescribed mainly to patients who had a definite diagnosis of CHF and who were also receiving digitalis.
|
|
|
|
| Discussion |
|---|
|
|
|---|
The practice of confirming home use of digitalis is likely to contribute to the preservation of the leading role this drug shares with diuretics in the treatment of CHF in general medicine and geriatrics wards. This practice has been associated with inappropriate prescription in a consistent proportion of patients (12)(15), but present findings do not support this conclusion: only 77 out of the 517 patients who were administered digitalis neither met the Carlson's criteria for CHF nor had atrial fibrillation. Nevertheless, a 15% prevalence of possibly inappropriate use should not be considered negligible, because these patients had mean age of 80 years and, thus, were at high risk of experiencing digitalis toxicity.
The association between older age and use of digitalis was not accounted for by the association of age and CHF or atrial fibrillation: 76.5% of subjects over 75 years receiving digitalis in the absence of a definite diagnosis of CHF did not suffer from atrial fibrillation; thus, aging might be a confounding factor leading to inappropriate digitalis prescription, and the high prevalence of noncardiogenic dyspnea and leg edema in elderly patients might be a clue to understanding this finding (15).
The association between COPD and in-hospital use of digitalis deserves some comment. The available evidence suggests that digitalis can benefit only COPD patients with a clinically significant left ventricular systolic dysfunction due to a coexisting disease (16). Given that the prevalence of such a dysfunction even in advanced COPD is quite low, the fact that 56.6% of our patients with COPD were given digitalis seems to indicate that COPD leads to incongruous digitalis prescription (17).
Only patients with a Carlson's score less than 5, and who were not given digitalis, had a clinical profile with a high degree of group specificity. This means that these patients are easily recognized on admission, whereas the same is not true of patients in the other groups. The poor degree of group specificity of clinical profiles suggests that patient-related variables cannot completely explain differences in group location and that physician-related variables, such as personal judgment and therapeutic practice in individual wards, might help in predicting whether a patient will or will not be prescribed digitalis.
This study has some limitations. Some variables that may be potentially explanatory, such as type of specialty of the prescribing physician, were not collected, and no gold-standard criteria can be recommended for the diagnosis of CHF (18). This difficulty in diagnosing CHF could account, to some extent, for the large overlap of clinical profiles of Group A to C. Furthermore, the age-related increasing prevalence of factors apt to confound the clinical presentation of CHF supports the conclusion that the complex discriminant model really reflects the difficulty in predicting which patient will be prescribed digitalis on the basis of the patient's clinical characteristics on admission.
In conclusion, the choice of adopting digitalis therapy cannot be reliably predicted on the account of clinical variables only, although some of these characterize patients who will be prescribed digitalis in the absence of a definite diagnosis of CHF. Exploring the cultural background of the prescriber could help limit the possible overuse of digitalis as well as promote the presently limited use of ACE inhibitors and beta blockers.
Received September 3, 1999
Accepted June 20, 2000
| Appendix |
|---|
|
|
|---|
0.5 (3), and upper-zone flow redistribution (2).
The maximum obtainable subscore in each category cannot exceed 4. To provide an example, a patient with interstitial pulmonary edema (p. 3), and cardiothoracic ratio
0.5 (p. 3) produces a total subscore of 4 in the category "Chest Radiography."
| Appendix B |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Chief Investigator: P.U. Carbonin
Investigators: M. Pahor, L. Carosella, R. Bernabei, C. Pedone, A. Sgadari, G. Onder
Software: M. Carli, M. Pavon
Technical support: G. Vagni
Acquaviva delle Fonti - Divisione di Gerontologia, Ospedale "Miulli" - V. Aloia, G. Baldassarre
Agnone (IS) - Divisione di Medicina, Ospedale Civile - P. Occhionero, P. Pescetelli
Ancona - Centro di Patologia Cardiovascolare, INRCA - E. Paciaroni, A. Andreoni, P. Angelini, L. Gigli, P.F. Tomassini
Ancona - INRCA, Ospedale Geriatrico - R. Gaetti, G. Cadeddu
Ancona - U.O. Medicina Geriatrica II, Istituto Geriatrico "U. Sestili" - G. De Tommaso, M. Badiali, F. Giovagnoli, F. Guidi
Appignano - INRCA - S. Bonaiuto, E. Giannandrea, L. Panichelli
Avellino - Dipartimento di Geriatria, Ospedale "Maffucci" - M. Lingetti, F. Di Grezia, A. Marro, E. Piermatteo, P. Sorrentino
Bari - Cattedra di Geriatria e Gerontologia, Università di Bari - A. Capurso, C. Capurso, D. Ciancia, N. Marella, G.A. Nardò, G. Nicoletti, F. Resta, G. Scicutella, V. Solfrizzi, G. Triggiani, A. Venezia, E. Vespertino
Bologna - Centro Studio Aterosclerosi, Ospedale Malpighi - A. Gaddi, B. Benassi, S. D'Addato, G. De Simone, A. Dormi, G. Magri, D. Pomata, N. Scol, E. Strocchi, G. Volta
Bologna - III Divisione Geriatrica, Ospedale Malpighi - D. Cucinotta, F. Cavazzuti, M. Corneli, R. Del Buono, P. Kalfus, R. Manopulo
Bologna - Patologia Medica I, Policlinico S. Orsola - G. Ravaglia, F. Boschi, M. Buttazzo, A. Cicognani, P. Forti, F. Maioli
Cagliari - Divisione di Geriatria, Ospedale SS. Trinità - M. Jovine, M.R. Frau, P.F. Putzu
Campobasso - Divisione di Medicina Interna, Ospedale Cardarelli - L. Carile, O. Grassi, T. Sanzò
Campoli del Monte (BN) - Divisione Cardiologica, Centro Medico di Riabilitazione - F. Rengo, N. Ferrara, A. Nicolino
Chiavari (GE) - RSA - P. Cavagnaro
Chieti - Clinica Geriatrica, Ospedale ex Pediatrico - G. Abate, S. Capasso, M.A. Cavoni, C. Cervone, L. D'Andrea, M. D'Aviero, F. Di Giangiacomo, A. Di Iorio, P. Lamanna, E. Marini, T. Palmerio, F. Pennese, A. Provenzano, G.M. Puddu, L. Savini, M. Zito
Chieti - Istituto di Clinica Medica, Università di Chieti - S. Sensi, A. Blasioli
Cortona (AR) - Unità Operativa di Medicina Generale, Ospedale Civile - M. Ricca, F. Cosmi, M. Margioni
Cosenza - INRCA - F. Corsonello, E. Cundari, G. Gaudio, B. Mazzei, L. Pranno, C. Zottola
Eboli (SA) - Divisione di Geriatria - L. D'Alessandro, V. Butrico, M.R. Coccaro, D. Di Biasi, R. Esposito, M. Mandia
Fano (AN) - Divisione di Geriatria, Ospedale S. Croce - M. Cuzzupoli, P. Candelora
Ferrara - Istituto di Medicina Interna II, Università di Ferrara - R. Fellin, A. Passaro, F. Romagnoni, S. Volpato, G. Zuliani
Firenze - Dipartimento di Farmacologia, Università di Firenze - A. Mugelli, E. Cecchi
Firenze - Patologia Medica IV, Università di Firenze - G. Gensini, E. Cangioli, S. Del Pace, S. Giomi, I. Simone
Firenze - Unità di Cura Intensiva Geriatrica, Università di Firenze - G. Masotti, N. Marchionni, E. Biondi, S. Fumagalli, L. Magherini, M. Marini, L. Matteucci
Foiano - Reparto di Medicina, Ospedale di Foiano - C. Pedace, S. Corsi, S. Simonetti
Genova - Cattedra di Gerontologia e Geriatria, Dipartimento di Medicina Interna - R. Balestreri, M.G. Carli, P. Cavagnaro, U. Compagnoni, Rita Pizzorno
Isernia - Divisione di Medicina, Ospedale "F. Veneziale" - E. Melaragno, G. Angelone, E. Calabrese, C. Disernia, I. Masciotra
Larino (CB) - Divisione di Medicina Generale, Ospedale Civile - F. Porfilio, N. Frate, A. Potena
Latina - UVG Ospedaliera, Ospedale "S. Maria Goretti" - S. Contini, M.A. Mangione
Loiano - Divisione di Medicina Interna, Ospedale "Simiani" - R. Nardi, D. Panuccio, A. Bernardini, M.R. Trabatti
Messina - Dipartimento di Medicina Interna - D. Ceruso, A. Allegra, S. Bonanzinga, C. Bontempo, L. Castagna, F. Corica, A. Corsonello, G. Cucinotta, T. De Gregorio, I. Granà, M. Pensabene, F. Rubino
Milano - Istituto di Medicina Interna, Università di Milano - P.M. Mannucci, D. Mari, P. Ferrazzi, M. Venturati
Milano - Istituto Pio Albergo Trivulzio - A.E. Tammaro, A. Borghese, G. Campiglio, A. Fuschini, L. Lago, C. Negri Chinaglia, L. Palvarini
Modena - Divisione di Geriatria, Ospedale Estense - G. Salvioli, S. Ascari, C. Mussi
Montefiascone - Ospedale di Montefiascone - Compagnoni
Napoli - Dipartimento di Geriatria, Università di Napoli - M. Varricchio, L. Amato, S. Ammendola, V. Balbi, G. Cennamo, A. Gambardella, R. Tortoriello
Napoli - IV Divisione di Medicina Interna, Università di Napoli - L. Saccà, V. Coto
Napoli - Istituto di Medicina Interna, II Facoltà di Medicina e Chirurgia - F. Rengo, P. Abete, P. Caccese, P. Landino
Novara - Clinica Medica III, Università di Torino - M. Aglietta, C. Franzini, M. Sartori, M. Ruzza, S. Andorno
Padova - III Divisione di Geriatria, Ospedale Geriatrico - O. De Candia, V. Bernini, M. Fabbris
Padova - Cattedra di Gerontologia e Geriatria, Università di Padova - G. Enzi, G. Belloni, E.N. Inelmen, M. D'Alessio, A. Girardi, M.G. De Dominicis, G. Himenez
Palermo - Divisione di Medicina Geriatrica, Ospedale "Villa Sofia" - A. Pardo, M.C. Fuschi, M. Pagano, M. Russotto, M. Sapienza, A. Spagnuolo
Palermo - Istituto di Medicina Interna e Geriatria, Università di Palermo - G. Barbagallo Sangiorgi, M. Barbagallo, G. Castiglione, G. Catania, G. Di Lorenzo, A. Di Sciacca, A. Geraci, M. Lo Bue, G. Lucania, F. Raspanti
Parma - Cattedra di Geriatria, Ospedale "G. Stuard" - G. Valenti, D. Magnani
Parma - Istituto di Clinica Medica Generale, Università di Parma - M. Passeri, M.C. Baroni, E. Courlios, A. De Blasio, R. Delsignore, R. Fiorini, S. Vourna
Perugia - Sezione di Gerontologia e Geriatria, Università di Perugia - U. Senin, S. Cesarini, A. Cherubini, M. Freddio, A. Longo, P. Mecocci, B. Salatino, P. Vagnarelli
Pontremoli - Divisione di Medicina, Ospedale S. Antonio Abate - A. Leone, P. Fabiano, A. Martelli
Prato - U.O. di Geriatria - A. Bavazzano, F. Boni, D. Calvani, R. Guarducci, M.L. Lunardelli, A. Mitidieri
Roma - Cattedra di Gerontologia e Geriatria, Policlinico Umberto I - V. Marigliano, P. Cicconetti, L. Capponi, M.G. Di Bernardo, C.F. Di Gioacchino, L. Persechino, F. Thau
Roma - Dipartimento di Medicina Clinica, Università La Sapienza - P. Serra, P. Carfagna, M. Gagliè, V. Paravati, A. Paris
Roma - Divisione di Geriatria e Sezione Cerebrolesi, Ospedale Israelitico - S.M. Zuccaro
Roma - Divisione di Medicina, Ospedale Fatebenefratelli - E. Bologna, A.M. Sidoti, D. Terracina, M. Di Girolamo
Roma - II Divisione Bassi, Ospedale S. Camillo - G.C. Nicotra, S. Pedace, S. De Maria, C. Bizzarri
Roma - Reparto di Clinica Medica, Università Cattolica del S. Cuore - C. Barone and colleagues
Roma - Reparto di Fisiopatologia Respiratoria, Università Cattolica del S. Cuore - G. Ciappi, S. Cardo, A. Carlucci, G.M. Corbo, G. Fumagalli, L. Fuso
Roma - Reparto di Geriatria, Università Cattolica del S. Cuore - A. Cocchi, F. Ardito, V. Cardone, M.G. Di Niro, F. Di Meo, L. Manigrasso, A. Russo, S. Urgese, G. Orsitto, V. Venturiero, G. Zuccalà
Roma - Medicina Degenze Speciali, Ospedale Militare Principale - M. Anaclerio, A. Greco, P. Pisanti
Roma - Divisione di Geriatria, Ospedale Addolorata - V. Lumia, G. Marangi, C. Carletta
Rovigo - Divisione di Geriatria, Ospedale Civile - P.L. Forte, A. Andriolli, C. Boscolo, E. Carbonin, S. Sparesato
S. Giovanni Rotondo - Divisione di Geriatria, Ospedale "Casa Sollievo della Sofferenza" - M. Giuliani, C. Ritrovato
S. Giovanni Rotondo - Divisione di Medicina, Ospedale "Casa Sollievo della Sofferenza" - R. Lucentini, A. Greco
Siena - Istituto di Semeiotica Medica e Geriatria, Nuovo Policlinico "Le Scotte" - S. Forconi, C. De Matteis, M. Guerrini, S. Gori, C. Iaccarino, F. Leoncini
Taranto - Medicina Generale, Ospedale "SS. Annunziata" - A. Marinosci, M.C. Bonanno, A. Di Gena, G. Lantone
Termoli (CB) - Reparto di Medicina, Ospedale Civile - M. Cariello, F. Baccari, V. Di Marco
Trento - U.O. Geriatria, Centro S. Chiara - G. Bertoluzza, G. Mansoldo, B. Bagozzi, E. Battisti, R. Garuti, M. Pavino, P. Sterzi, G. Tava
Trieste - Istituto di Clinica Medica, Università di Trieste - L. Cattin, C. Adamo, G. Carmignani, E. Grande, R. La Verde
Verona - I Divisione Geriatrica, Ospedale Civile Maggiore - G. Zavateri, C. Bellamoli, G. Beltrami, L. Bettili, M.P. Conti, C. Di Battisti, P. Garzotti, P. Peroli, G. Raschellà, C. Ruggiano
Vicenza - Ospedale Civile - G. Valerio, F. Azzini, E. Bianchi, F. Gioia
| References |
|---|
|
|
|---|
This article has been cited by other articles:
![]() |
G. Zuccala, G. Onder, E. Marzetti, M. R. L. Monaco, M. Cesari, A. Cocchi, P. Carbonin, R. Bernabei, and for the GIFA Study Group Use of angiotensin-converting enzyme inhibitors and variations in cognitive performance among patients with heart failure Eur. Heart J., February 1, 2005; 26(3): 226 - 233. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
A. Ahmed, R. M. Allman, and J. F. DeLong Inappropriate Use of Digoxin in Older Hospitalized Heart Failure Patients J. Gerontol. A Biol. Sci. Med. Sci., February 1, 2002; 57(2): M138 - 143. [Abstract] [Full Text] |
||||
![]() |
J. E. Morley Editorial: Drugs, Aging, and the Future J. Gerontol. A Biol. Sci. Med. Sci., January 1, 2002; 57(1): M2 - 6. [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
G. Zuccala, G. Onder, C. Pedone, L. Carosella, M. Pahor, R. Bernabei, and A. Cocchi Hypotension and cognitive impairment: Selective association in patients with heart failure Neurology, December 11, 2001; 57(11): 1986 - 1992. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
| ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| HOME | ARCHIVE | SEARCH | TABLE OF CONTENTS |
|---|